Find Out More

  • Accreditations
  • Join our Team
  • Terms of Business
  • Pricing Information
  • Client Feedback
    • Leave a Review
  • Complaints
  • Regulatory Information
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • Skip to footer navigation
  • Skip to secondary navigation

Harold Stock & Co. Solicitors

Rooted in the community

  • Mossley:
    01457 835597
  • Failsworth:
    0161 682 2400
  • Stockport:
    0161 456 5012
  • Get In Touch
  • Home
  • About
    • Our Team
    • CSR
  • Legal Services
    • Personal Injury
    • Medical Negligence
    • Serious Injury
    • Commercial and Company
    • Family Law
    • Property
    • Wills, Probate And The Elderly
  • News
  • Contact
  • More

Court of Appeal rules that a divorced partner can challenge his former mother-in- law’s Will

3rd May 2016 by Harold Stock & Co

When can you challenge a Will? When do you, in the court’s opinion, have a valid to bring a case and challenge the express wishes of the bereaved? That was the question put before the courts in the recent case of Randall v Randall. The answer, according to the Court of Appeal’s latest decision, is when you have ‘sufficient interest’ in the Will to bring a case.

In the case, Colin Randall, a divorced husband, sought permission to challenge the validity of his former mother-in- law’s Will which left him nothing from her estate. The case centred on whether Mr Randall had ‘sufficient interest’ in the Will to allow him to bring a claim alleging that it had been forged in an attempt to defeat an order made in divorce proceedings.

As part of an earlier divorce settlement, his wife, Hilary Randall had agreed that if she inherited more than £100,000 from her mother, anything over £100,000 would be split equally between her and her husband. After the mother died her Will left £100,000 to Mrs Randall, and the balance of the estate – around £150,000 – was left to the wife’s children.

Mr Randall then launched proceedings to challenge the validity of the will. However, Deputy Master Collaço Moraes found that he did not have sufficient interest in the Will, and therefore had no standing to bring a claim.

The case then proceeded to the Court of Appeal. Barrister Mark Baxter, acting for Mrs Randall, argued that the only people who could challenge a Will were those who had the right to administer the estate. He argued that as Mr Randall was not entitled to administer his mother-in- law’s estate, he was a ‘stranger to the estate’ and therefore did not have sufficient interest to bring a claim.

However in the Court of Appeal, Master of the Rolls Lord Dyson, ruled that ‘justice in the general sense requires the husband to bring a probate claim to set aside the Will.’ He noted that the overriding interest set by the procedural code was to deal with cases justly. Lord Dyson therefore argued that if Mr Randall did not have an interest in the estate, there would have no other route by which he could challenge the validity of the Will:

‘If this claim did not fall within the probate jurisdiction, but fell within the general jurisdiction of the court, it is obvious that [Mr Randall] would have a sufficient interest in the subject-matter of this litigation to bring the claim.’

‘He is not a mere busybody. He has a real interest in challenging the validity of the will.’

In judgement Lord Justice McCombe concurred, saying:

‘It appears to me to be highly unjust that if, in circumstances similar to the present, a Will had been forged in an attempt to defeat an order made in divorce proceedings, the party affected could not challenge the validity of the Will in probate proceedings.’ Lady Justice King also agreed.

Filed Under: Family, Wills and probate

Avatar

Harold Stock & Co

Related

Wills – what to think about before an appointment
5th February 2021
Categories: Blog, News, Wills and probate
Can I make a Will during lockdown?
18th January 2021
Categories: Blog, News, Wills and probate
Couples feeling the strain?
18th January 2021
Categories: Blog, Family, News

Footer

harold stock logo
  • Accreditations
  • Join our Team
  • Terms of Business
  • Pricing Information
  • Client Feedback
    • Leave a Review
  • Complaints
  • Regulatory Information
  • Acceptable Use
  • Complaints
  • Email Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy/Cookies
  • Regulatory Information
  • Terms of Website Use
harold stock solicitors

Mossley (Head Office)

55-57 Stamford Street
Mossley
Tameside OL5 0LN

Tel: 01457 835597
Fax: 0330 024 9210

harold stock solicitors

Failsworth

Ivy Business Centre
Crown Street
Failsworth M35 9PB

Tel: 0161 682 2400
Fax: 0330 024 9210

harold stock solicitors

Stockport

Oak House
483 Buxton Road
Stockport SK2 7HE

Tel: 0161 456 5012
Fax: 0330 024 9210

Email: info@haroldstock.com

  • Instagram

Harold Stock & Co Solicitors is a trading name of Harold Stock & Co Limited, a Limited Company registered in England and Wales. Company No: 07201476. Registered Office: 55-57 Stamford Street, Mossley, Tameside, OL5 0LN. Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (535629). VAT No: 991 015 916 A full list of Directors is available at the Company’s Registered Office.

  • Acceptable Use
  • Complaints
  • Email Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy/Cookies
  • Regulatory Information
  • Terms of Website Use

Company Registered in England and Wales. No. 07201476
Copyright © 2021
Log in
Instilled Ltd

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.Accept
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.